Hello! This will be another quick post. I have recently started making yogurt again after a break. With that yogurt I can make peanut butter popsicles! My children love these. Okay…we all love these! They are super simple and require only a few ingredients. Actual individual ingredients. It always drove me nuts looking for recipes online to find ingredients with ingredients when I was trying to look for simple recipes that were decently healthy. Now, I am not calling this healthy but it is simple and not full of additives.
Folks looking for an exact recipe, hold on to your seats! This will not be that! I do not measure, but I will give you an idea. The ingredients I use are peanut butter, plain yogurt, maple syrup and a pinch or two of salt. I make my own peanut butter and do not add salt which is why I add it in the recipe. If you are using peanut butter that is salted, omit the salt.
I use approximately 1 quart of plain yogurt, around a cup of peanut butter, and pure maple syrup to taste plus a pinch or two of salt for depth of flavor. I blend these up in my blender. That is the first part. One you blend that up, pour it into a popsicle mold but do not fill to the top. The recipe gets yummier in a moment when we make what I call peanut butter caramel.
Okay, on to the caramel! This is also super simple. Take about a cup of peanut butter and add some maple syrup to taste plus a pinch or two of salt if using plain peanut butter. Mix these up and add blobs to the already filled mold. This is why you needed to leave some space. Also freezing does expand the liquid contents.
Sorry for the fuzzy photo. I didn’t see that it came out that way until it was too late to retake. I used it anyway because I wanted to show you what it looks like! Next, put the top on the mold and add popsicle sticks. Lastly, put them in the freezer. It is that simple!
I had left over mixtures so added them to my favorite Kerr jars for individual ice creams and sorbets. I also love these for jams and jellies. They are short and squatty which makes them easier to stack on shelves. I will provide a link below for everything I used here. Don’t forget to leave space for expansion when using glass in the freezer. You also need to use straight jars. Not doing so can result in broken glass and wasted food.
The fuzzy pictures were from the way I angled the camera with the sunlight apparently. Here is what I had left over using these 8 ounce jars. I put lids on them and popped them in the freezer. Done! Nut butters make fantastic ice cream bases because of the fat content. They make ice cream rich and creamy. They are also a nice source of protein. I hope you enjoy this recipe!
This post contains affiliate links, which means I make a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Coming Home to Eden is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
